NEW ALBANY, Ind. (WDRB) — A former treasurer for the Floyd Central High School Band Booster Association is accused of stealing nearly $25,000 from the nonprofit, leaving some parents who supported the program feeling betrayed.
According to court documents, Nicola Jackson faces theft, forgery and corrupt business influence charges after the organization discovered discrepancies in her handling of funds.
Jackson served as treasurer of the school's band booster association from 2022-24, giving her access to the organization's checking accounts, checkbook and debit card.
When Jackson was replaced as treasurer in June 2024, the new treasurers quickly noticed several inconsistencies in the group's bank records, including charges for mortgage payments, salon expenses and car repairs.
A probable cause affidavit claims Jackson stole $24,752.89 over three school years.
Investigators said Jackson admitted using the band's account for personal expenses but claimed she repaid the money. However, there was no evidence the funds were reimbursed.
One boosters parent said the situation shook the trust among families involved with the program.
"At the end of the day, this isn't just about money," said the parent, who asked not to be identified. "It's about trust. Parents entrusted this program with both our financial support and the daily care of our children. When something this serious happens and families are left in the dark, it damages confidence in the very system that is supposed to support and protect our students."
In a written statement Thursday, New Albany Floyd County Schools Superintendent Travis Madison said Jackson was suspended Dec. 16 and fired Jan. 7 after an internal investigation.
Jackson's name no longer appears on Floyd Central High School's staff page.
Some boosters parents said the district didn't inform them about the alleged theft, and some said they were unaware Jackson was fired.
"Due to an ongoing investigation, we are unable to comment further at this time," Madison said.
Jackson’s attorney, Evan Ray, said that in his 18-year career, he has seen many cases like this that involve what he called a "rush to judgment."
Jackson was released from jail on bond. Her pre-trial is scheduled for April 9.
Copyright 2026 WDRB Media. All Rights Reserved.
